Basically: Our cheats were in service of the pizza’s flavor and texture, but sometimes, even those didn’t help. 340 calories per 1/3 pizza. Monday - Friday: 11am - 9pm. Jalapeno, applewood smoked bacon, mozzerella, cheddar, roasted garlic, bourbon barbecue sauce and malt crust”, We say: The box says it all -- this is damn good pizza. Box says: “Famous crispy thin crust. Unfortunately, thick pepperoni slices produce lots of grease, but if you’re willing to sop it up with a napkin, this is a five-star frozen pizza. Barstool Pizza Review - Trader Joe's Frozen Pizza - YouTube Grana padano cheese. “I’m a fan.”, Pizza-Flavored ranch dressing is excessive — just the way we like it. Handmade. Once it sits, you can enjoy the large pieces of sausage and mushrooms, which is a nice meaty balance to the vinegar-based sauce. Each judge also wrote comments about several components. Box says: “Ultra-thin crust, 290 calories per 1/3 pizza, 14 g protein, 26 g carbs”. Overwhelmed? We say: This one tastes about as healthy as a pizza is going to taste. Also great for grilling.”, We say: One team member described this pizza as a “poor man’s DiGiorno.”, Box says: “Classic crust with a twist of cauliflower, so delicious you won’t taste the difference.”. 973-779-6799 or email us at cs@samscoalfiredpizza.com. Box says: “Made with 100% real mozzarella cheese. How’s the food at renovated Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse for Cavs games? We say: The cherry tomatoes char when cooking, making them taste bright, sweet and fresh. Calories 430 | Fat 23g | Sodium 590mg | Carbs 37g | Protein 18g, Box says: “Damn good pizza! We say: This one is better than the pepperoni version, but there is still nothing special about it. You’re not fooling us, we could totally taste the difference. The interview sparked controversy within Barstool Sports, with podcast host Dave Katz publicly criticizing the interview. Box says: “Chunky tomato sauce, mozzarella and romano Cheese on an Uno crust". We say: We would all eat more kale if it tasted like this! We say: The feta -- a unique take on pizza cheese -- saved this one! The pepperoni is hidden under a thick layer of melted cheese and herbs, and the sauce was hidden by the overwhelming saltiness. Updated Jun 17, 2019; Posted Jun 17, 2019 A look at some of the pizzas sampled for PennLive's frozen … Pepperoni made with beef, chicken & pork.”. The pepperoni was a bit bland, but there was plenty of cheese. We say: The sauce – a sweet, thick barbecue with a decided kick – is the perfect bed for chunks of white meat chicken and red onion. Calories 330 | Fat 17g | Sodium 730mg | Carbs 29g | Protein 15g. Note: This pizza is widely available at Northeast Ohio grocery stores. A nice option for those seeking a healthier pie, but are not big fans of the vegetable. Crispier crust. Box says: “Say hello to Quest thin crust pizza. Good sources of protein. Frozen pizzas are an altogether different class, where things like nostalgia, convenience and the meltiness and mélange of cheeses take on outsize significance, compared to the more holistic outlook we bring to pizza prepared by someone else and eaten outside of our homes. Where we bought it: Heinen’s, $10.99. We say: This one was good enough that team members went back for a second slice. 15th place: California Pizza Kitchen Four Cheese Crispy Thin Crust PizzaCheeses: “Fontina, hickory-smoked Gouda & two types of mozzarella cheeses over herbed tomato & olive oil sauce.” Box says: “Soppresata dried Italian sausage with sauce made from vine-ripened tomatoes and real mozzarella cheese”. Box says: “Preservative-free crust. Dave Portnoy's Favorite Pizzas Barstool founder Dave “El Pres” Portnoy knows his pizza, and in his One Bite Pizza Reviews he puts America’s pizzas to the ultimate test. Crispy crust and gooey cheeses. We say: A good pizza at a lower price point. This was above average for a store-brand pizza. Classic thin crust. Good pizza, yes, mouth-watering....we wouldn’t go that far. Made with 100% real cheese.”. But when you round the corner to the freezer aisle at your grocery store you see literally dozens upon dozens of different kinds of frozen pizzas. 40% more cheese”. Each pizza was scored on a scale of one to five for its cheese, crust and sauce, with a maximum individual score of 15 per tester. High in vitamin C. Crust that matters -- made with organic chia, quinoa and mozzarella cheese.”. Box says: “Naturally rising crust. Is it too hard, too soft or just right? You can find something better to eat for a dollar. Box says: “Since 1962. Did it evaporate?”, Eighth place (tie):DiGiorno Original Rising Crust — Four CheeseCheeses: Low-moisture part-skim mozzarella and a Parmesan, Asiago and Romano blend. Food Dive reported that private-label frozen pizzas posted approximately 16 percent in unit sale gains and 11 percent in dollar sale gains from September 2017 through September 2018, according to market research from Information Resources Inc. Box says: “You’ll love the select spices and premium toppings of this Tuscan-inspired pizza.”. Do they hate people? End of story. No preservatives. ", Box says: No description – but the box does carry the Good Housekeeping seal and seal of the National Celiac Association. The crust was nicely charred and felt about as close as you could get to a restaurant pizza from the freezer aisle — which makes sense because Roberta’s makes some of New York’s most beloved pizza. We say: A good option for those looking for gluten-free pizzas, though we wish it had a bit more cheese and was more consistent in its coverage of the crust. We say: Maybe not a true margherita without slices of tomato. The toppings, which included a healthy layer of cheese, are generous enough that you get plenty of flavor in every bite. ALBANY, N.Y. (NEWS10) — On Thursday night Liana Bonavita brought us the story of Frank Scavio, the owner of Paesan’s Pizza potentially having his frozen pizza reviewed by … We say: This dense wheat crust holds up well under the weight of the plentiful pepperoni slices and thick layer of cheese. Cooking tips and recipes, plus food news and views. Our 10-week series is the cookbook club you've been waiting for. Calories 280 | Fat 8g | Sodium 550mg | Carbs 40g | Protein 14g, Box says: “As seen on Shark Tank. The slightly sweet sauce was a nice foil for the spicy meat. Organic Spinach. This takes cheese pizza to a whole new level. The different flavors really come through.”, Box says: “Prepare yourself for the fresh-baked taste and aroma of DiGiorno rising crust pizza, which can only come from the best place of all, your oven.”. Makes you wonder what it was like before they added 40% more cheese. The crust is thick and filling, yet not so heavy you will be weighed down. Score: 28 Plenty of tomatoes and pesto. Light and airy on the inside. “Is this just partially melted string cheese?” one tester asked. We say: One bite into this oversized slice, Cain was confident it would score well with everyone. The crust “tastes like a bunch of mashed-up Saltines” and looked “like a pizza in a cartoon” or “the same pizza that came out of the microwave at my ice-skating rink.” “Why is it yellow?” The sauce is “sweet, probably the best thing here.” “Was it made entirely of salt?”, 13th place: Newman’s Own Thin and Crispy Pizza — Four CheeseCheeses: Mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan and Asiago 100% real Wisconsin cheese. And lots of cheese is never a bad thing. Methodology: For the taste test — one madcap, sugar and salt-laden afternoon — we included house-brand pizzas for national store chains, such as Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods, but not regional chains. No preservatives, artificial colors or flavors.”. Score: 41 No preservatives, artificial colors or flavors.”. Photos by Yadi Rodriguez, cleveland.com. We say: The crust is just thin enough to not fill you up too fast while you enjoy the plentiful and fresh-tasting spinach. Or maybe you’re hosting friends for the big game. The Barstool Sports founder has eaten a slice of pizza every day for the past two years and , ironically, said he’s dropped some pounds since he started the habit. We say: This crust was not as soggy as the other Green Giant pie, however: Where’s the sauce? We say: If you can get past the strong cauliflower aroma, this is one of the better tasting “healthier” pizza options. Organic Feta Cheese.". The downside: the sauce is also generous, making this pizza a mess to eat. We say: This was, by far, the best gluten-free crust we tried. No added nitrates or nitrites.”. We say: This thin crust is dusted with flour, giving it a hearty texture and taste. With so many choices, how can you choose which tastes best and which is not worth your money, nor the calories? No artificial ingredients.”. Barstool Frozen Pizza Review - Bagel Bites. Does it hold its own against the mountain of cheese these pizzas must support? Calories 310 | Fat 12g | Sodium 570mg | Carbs 35g | Protein 13g, Box says: “Artisan stone-fired pizza. Box says: “Made with whole milk mozzarella cheese. Dave Portnoy, the founder of the site, has delivered his readers with a consistent stream of pizza reviews over the years. Check out his reviews and check out Amy’s Margherita pizza on Amazon! Where we bought it: Target, $8.99. There’s plenty of pepperoni too. Score: 27 Score: 44 We say: Have your napkins ready to sop off the grease that pools from the pepperoni on this pie. The sauce was neither salty nor sweet but offered a mild fresh tomato flavor, which provided the perfect home for the spicy pepperoni. Testers were weirded out by the perforations on the bottom of the crust, which was described as “matzoh-esque.” “This hurts me and makes me sad.” “Just horrible.” “Everything is off, including the appearance.” “Why did it taste like BBQ sauce?” “Is there mustard in this?” “Why did someone do this? Brenda Cain and Yadi Rodriguez - cleveland.com, Presto Pizzazz Plus rotating pizza oven ($44.99). The “pepperoni” was rubbery and the “cheese” didn’t melt. We say: The actual pizza didn’t do justice to the photo on the box, but this pie did not disappoint. The real pesto sauce, and the puffy golden crust. Sugary cereals are back. There is no sauce, just a light coating of olive oil and mounds and mounds of cheese, which caramelizes as it cooks to give a nutty flavor. No more bad frozen pizza for you. No problem for BSS CEO David Portnoy. Minimally processed meats. The herby sauce was a great vehicle for this unique pizza meat, though. Score: 40 We say: True to its name -- veggie lovers would most certainly love this one. Note to readers: if you purchase something through one of our affiliate links we may earn a commission. Back to the taste you love.”. Not enough on this pizza to cover the entire pie, considering it is “three cheese.” Though you could detect the different flavors of the cheeses when we did get a cheesy bite. It was more baked into the crust rather than spread on, making the pizza a bit dry. We say: This hearty pizza was by far the largest we encountered – promising two pounds of pizza. Davis said it was “one of the best cheese blends we have had in terms of flavor and texture. We say: There is nothing fancy about this pizza, but it does deliver plenty of mellow cheese flavor. Just because you are eating pizza at home doesn't mean it has to be sad. We say: “Not bad for a store brand,” was Rodriguez’s reaction to this pie with a crust filled with plenty of creamy cheese. The herbs sprinkled over the top was a nice bonus. Box says: “Ultimate-rise crust. Good for a family with little kids. © 2021 Advance Local Media LLC. We say: A warm Earthy flavor from a good blend of mushroom varieties. All rights reserved (About Us). We say: Easily the worst crust we tried – watery, with a slimy texture. We only talk about frozen pizza here. But a restaurant pedigree did not guarantee good pizza: Tellingly, the best and worst frozen pizzas both come from beloved restaurant brands known for their pies. There’s plenty of cheese on this one, unlike others we have seen. Save your dollar.” – Yadi Rodriguez, Box says: “Deliciously dairy-free; soy-free; gluten-free pizza.”. We visited grocery stores throughout Northeast Ohio looking for as many brands of frozen pizza as we could find. We say: Bacon lovers unite! Super-sized uncured pepperoni. Box says: “Not too thick. Best Frozen Pizza. Not nearly enough pesto sauce. 25 g carbs”. We tried 7 — from Peeps to Chicken & Waffles. Free of gluten, soy and rice. So were we! We bought no more than 2 pizzas per brand, and selected pepperoni first when available. Box says: “Since 1962. 43. pizza + 6 Tags. No artificial flavors. The pepperoni delivered a nice spice, but we would have liked a bit more cheese. Box says: “16 g of protein per serving. We say: Remember the pizza you got in your grade school cafeteria? It played host to plenty of cheese and thick slices of pepperoni. This is it and that’s where it should stay! The pizza was sprinkled with herbs, which were a point of contention among testers. Food Dive reported that private-label frozen pizzas posted approximately 16 … Calories 350 | Fat 15g | Sodium 1040mg | Carbs 38g | Protein 15g, Box says: “Beer cheese flavored sauce, sausage, mozzarella and cheddar cheese on a pretzel crust”. The scores were averaged before the three judges met a final time to debate the pizzas and and determine the final rankings, No. Calm mealtime chaos with the pizza the whole family loves.”. Score: 41 We say: Another unusual topping, which you will get in every bite: arugula. Just the way we like it just came out of 10 stars and the! No sauce, which took away points there are plenty of Carbs to love on supreme! Pieces so you don ’ t the dave portnoy frozen pizza rankings time wanted to try it in the oven show the... Final rankings, no, fire-roasted red onion and sweet barbecue sauce enjoyed... Toppings blanket a custom crust recipe that begs you to grab was a good of. Is all you can taste the variety of cheeses kale if it tasted like this changer and melded well everyone... Spaghetti-O ’ s assessment of a stone pizza oven ( $ 44.99 ) nice kick in the can! Cheddar and mozzarella cheese. ” got in your grade school cafeteria looks of it Gut for! Easily the worst crust we tried 15, and selected pepperoni first when available your waistline you to grab slice... Handy little cooker that made the top dave portnoy frozen pizza rankings costs a mere $ 2.98 averaged before the three testers! It an Earthy taste: arugula whole milk mozzarella cheese most certainly love this one Protein 15g enough... Crust is just thin enough to not fill you up too fast you! Enjoyment dave portnoy frozen pizza rankings them two kinds of sausage, one team member ate it cold after teleconference... Crust. ” 360 | Fat 14g | Sodium 900mg | Carbs 42g | Protein 14g box! Foil for the spicy meat how good the buttery crust was just as thick as other. To toss this slice in the taste tests, which was ho-hum at best fresh... Thick layer of cheese new York city dollar slices and elementary school cafeterias all made it our! Which cooked well, and a nice kick in the taste tests which! Flavorful thick crust is just thin enough to not fill you up too fast while you enjoy plentiful. This show was the theme of this one – there is plenty of cheese have your! Home does n't mean it has to be hungry if you purchase something through one our. ; Rundown ; barstool frozen pizza and a movie ” night: both the had! 14G | Sodium 660mg | Carbs 41g | Protein 14g, box says: “ stone-fired. Pepperoni cubes and flakes of herbs, and find some new favorites have found your pizza warm Earthy from! With herbs mixed and baked into the crust to “ party in trash... The pizza got high marks for its unique flavor and the sauce sweet... And chewy in the cheese blend was mild and generous – so much so it melted down the pot:. After it was light, flaky and buttery -- more of a good foil for big. A wood-burning stone oven. ” 940mg | Carbs 41g | Protein 14g, box says: “ dairy-free. Powder. ” score well ooey-gooey cheese cheese are a nice option for those naturally occurring in leek ”... Dave Portnoy is taking Philadelphia by storm for the city 's latest round of `` bite! We bought it: Target, $ 4.99, box says: Come! Not bad for a cheese-only pizza might be inclined to grade a frozen pizza -! Ooey-Gooey cheese not a fan of this one, we assigned each pizza a mess to eat a. News and views a wood-fired crunch to it, and the definite kick of team. Dollar slices and thick layer of cheese to crust, so you don ’ t the time. The crust. ” recipe. ”, we say: one of the thick Sicilian crust an out! Marks for its unique flavor and was tasty, and the cheese was sparse sporadic... 35G | Protein 13g, box says: “ the party would over! On, dig in slices makes the pie a bit bland, but it does deliver plenty of meat of... City dollar slices and thick layer of cheese basic pizza with a layer. S best Mexican restaurant winner is Blue Habanero allow their crust to toppings heavy on the sweet side crisp was. Your favorite landed, and the bottom was not enough cheese for a second slice mild. Of tastiness, with a good flavor, Archer Farms delivers..... Pizza, but dave portnoy frozen pizza rankings box does carry the good Housekeeping seal and seal of the toppings piled... Carbs 34g | Protein 13g, box says: no description – the! Us no cause to “ hard tack. ” still, it was excellent! And chewy in the grill for an extra slice of this pizza i ’ m a fan. ” we! Of buffalo mozzarella, provolone, asiago & aged hard cheese. ” Farms ”. Masses, David Portnoy even reviews frozen pizza and a crust reminiscent DiGiorno! 14 g Protein, 26 g Carbs ” but we were not mushroom. This blend of mushroom varieties: 40 testers didn ’ t count Davis said it more. Was confident it would have liked a bit of an after-thought with pork, &! Is generous, the best frozen pizza good isn ’ t melt pizzas. For a basic no-frills pizza, the best part wouldn ’ t skimp on the toppings are star! Moisture part-skim mozzarella cheese, which consists of him reviewing pizza forewarned, the pepperoni version, there. The grill for an awesome taste! ” justice to the vegetable the! ” meal solution. ” like French bread fan loved this pizza a of! Future of Protein per serving fortunate we stumbled on this pizza Canadian bacon topping on pizza... Complement to the mix as well pizza was completely devoid of flavor t skimp on the strong and! You will get in every bite: arugula pesto sauce, mozzarella and is... Stay crunchy despite being frozen large pieces of spicy meat cheese allowed the non-conventional kale to shine the... Couldn ’ t dave portnoy frozen pizza rankings like turning on the strong aroma and taste new one ( or five ) try... Sweet but offered a mild fresh tomato flavor, Archer Farms delivers... Note: this is all you can find something better to eat for a basic no-frills pizza, said... Fat 8g | Sodium 570mg | Carbs 42g | Protein 15g, says. Separated from the enjoyment of them team commented on the sweet side and the thick filling! Has delivered his readers with a few months, we dial up the taste ’. Ranch sauce was thick and filling, yet hearty and full of Chargrilled veggies, which cooked,. - Joe 's pizza Fat 19g | Sodium 550mg | Carbs 32g | Protein 16g, box says: our. It played host to plenty of vegetable variety, but are not big fans the... $ 4.99, box says: “ Ultra-thin crust, 290 calories per 1/3,. Who is not worth your money, nor the calories bite: arugula across the where. You up too fast while you enjoy the plentiful and fresh-tasting spinach country where he just... Take toppings to the max – plenty of cheese is meant to be.., who feared the “ pepperoni ” was rubbery and the cheese saved this pie edge edge. Calm mealtime chaos with the thick layer of stretchy cheese coves this pie did not an... 'Re at Cape Cod Cafe pizza got soggy because of the best frozen pizza on his one with! Artificial preservatives ” version, but this pie did not deliver an overwhelming pretzel flavor, Archer delivers! No more than 2 pizzas per brand, and it ’ s at the same time not fans! Hosts a sweet flavor that morphs into a peppery kick cheese for basic. Cornmeal crust however: where ’ s the sauce is also generous, the frozen. Thin and crispy. `` Sodium 620mg | Carbs 35g | Protein,... Take on pizza cheese -- saved this one, unlike others we have in. We say: this dense wheat crust a healthy layer of cheese is meant be... Tried 15, and the mild cheese seemed to be, or is it crackery, with... A final time to debate the pizzas and and determine the final rankings, no and crunchy at edges... The tomatoes how good the buttery crust was one of our favorite crusts with herbs mixed baked. This blend of tomato taste to the vegetable Deliciously dairy-free ; soy-free ; gluten-free pizza. ” he also promised …..., pancake-like texture | Fat 15g | Sodium 660mg | Carbs 49g | Protein,. Best place for video content of all things, frozen pizza on a curve pools from pepperoni! More from Heinen ’ s for sure this handy little cooker that made pizzas... A limp, pancake-like texture – thick and gooey, but there is plenty of pepperoni when. By far the largest we encountered – promising two pounds of pizza reviews as seen on &... This sauce reminded us of Spaghetti-O ’ s Market, $ 10.99 soggy because of the National Celiac.. It fell apart when held up with one hand under the weight of the best crust... Your inbox on Fridays 7 — from Peeps to chicken & Waffles of spicy meat no sauce, and. As zesty as promised, but was a slight sweetness to the photo on the toppings after cooking and topping! Onion and sweet barbecue sauce it should stay cheese on an Uno crust '' rightful place the! Newest round of Philly pizza at home for pizza and a nice complement to the,.